Cult Cinema: The Temptation of St. Tony (2009) - Reviewed

Courtesy of Olive Films
Not a whole lot is known about contemporary Estonian cinema which first began in 1896 with the first moving pictures screened in Tallinn followed by a checkered century including but not limited to the evolution of Soviet cinema.  After the fall of the Soviet Union, Estonia began rediscovering its own unique footing in the global cinematic terrain around 1997 with the formulation of the Estonian Film Foundation.  In a curious development around the mid-2000s, then-newcomer Estonian writer-director Veiko Õunpuu established in his second feature The Temptation of St. Tony (Püha Tõnu kiusamine) what could be characterized as spring boarding from the provocative and affronting wisdom of Soviet master filmmaker Aleksei German or British director Peter Greenaway. 

Courtesy of Olive Films

Opening on a quotation from Dante’s Divine Comedy, we find middle-aged well-to-do manager Tõnu (Taavi Eelmaa) leading the procession of his father’s funeral on a beach when a car flips over nearby and crashes on the shoreline.  The funeral continues unabated by the vehicular accident as the injured and bloodied passenger crawls out of the wreckage before stumbling upon Tõnu.  He offers to drive the man to the hospital who is just tickled pink to be sitting inside such a luxurious vehicle.  Thus begins The Temptation of St. Tony which follows Tõnu through a series of increasingly surreal and nightmarish misadventures as the ground of the film begins to go out from under its morally conflicted “hero”.

Courtesy of Olive Films

Divided by chapters in a Dante-esque structure as the film’s hero repeatedly encounters a strange but beautiful woman (Ravshana Kurkova) interspersed with bizarre anecdotes.  Leading towards a Twin Peaks influenced nightclub known as the Golden Age including but not limited to human trafficking, naked dancing and cannibalism, The Temptation of St. Tony is an episodic journey into the netherworld as Tõnu wrestles with ever developing moral quandaries.  Not unlike Polish maestro Andrzej Żuławski’s The Devil, the film sets off a series of anarchic visionary cinematic explosions before the cameras with a morally complex antihero at the epicenter trying to make sense of the nihilistic and amoral world he lives in.

Co-starring the great Denis Levant (Leos Carax’s partner-in-crime), The Temptation of St. Tony is stunningly photographed by Mart Taniel and boasts an unforgettable original electronic score by Ülo Krigul which fluctuates freely between ambience, dance techno and eventually a Ligeti-esque series of choral requiems on the soundtrack.  Wholly sonically and visually arresting from top to bottom, the film also boasts brilliant production design which garnered Markku Pätilä and Jaagup Roomet a European Film Awards nomination, moving from the craggy open terrain of forests and swamps decorated with human limbs into a labyrinthine subterrain manmade structure that feels otherworldly. 

Courtesy of Olive Films

Performances across the board are solid with Taavi Eelmaa perfectly expressing the protagonist’s sense of growing terror and confusion and Ravshana Kurkova exuding purity and innocence in a world keen on corruption of everything.  Levant’s brilliant cameo as Count Dionysos Korzybski is sure to leave even the staunchest of Carax fans scratching their heads and the grand guignol finale will no doubt trigger unpleasant memories of Peter Greenaway’s still searing masterwork The Cook, the Thief, His Wife & Her Lover.

Despite the film’s frightening and bleak tone, The Temptation of St. Tony is at times impishly playful with how it seems to throw caution to the wind and dive headfirst into extreme absurdism.  Closest to Aleksei German’s still stomach-churning cinematic monument Khrustalyov, My Car! in terms of presenting an episodic free for all into madness and mayhem, Õunpuu’s second feature cements the Estonian writer-director as a new young prodigy to watch for with baited-breath. 

Courtesy of Olive Films

In what is surely one of the most original voices in new world cinema, The Temptation of St. Tony doesn’t play nice or fair and is often difficult if not an irascible picture to watch but at the heart of it all is Õunpuu’s uniquely farcical sense of…fun?  For as awful as things get here, there’s something about The Temptation of St. Tony that’ll manage to leave a smirk on your face. 

--Andrew Kotwicki