MVD Visual: Navajo (1952) - Reviewed

Courtesy of MVD Visual
Actor/director/screenwriter Norman Foster, best known for directing a good number of the Charlie Chan and Mr. Moto films as well as working for Orson Welles and Walt Disney at different points of his career, was a seasoned filmmaking veteran well before arriving on his 1952 Oscar nominated docudrama Navajo, a film which was all but forgotten until being rescued and restored by Kit Parker Films who oversaw a 2K restoration.  

Starting out a bit like Robert Flaherty’s stagey Nanook of the North as a quasi-documentary portrait of Native American life, focusing on Son of the Hunter (Francis Kee Teller) before taking on the shape of a scenic chase thriller involving American Indian boarding schools set on separating children from their biological families and forced to conform to the white man’s way of life. 
 
Among the only Hollywood films about the erasing nature of the boarding school system determined to eradicate preexisting cultural norms in Native Americans, the film is largely told through voiceover narration from the perspective of Son of the Hunter, played brilliantly by then seven-year-old Francis Kee Teller.  


Unlike Nanook of the North which carefully hid ordinary Eskimo customs from the cameras to make them seem more westernized, Navajo offers clearer but still somewhat censored insight into Native American life for the first half of the picture before shifting gears to a traditional thriller when Son of the Hunter finds himself separated from his mother and abducted by white men who assign him to a boarding school.  From here, Son of the Hunter plots his escape, all set to the stunningly beautiful canyon backdrops of Arizona.
 
From top to bottom, Navajo is visually striking with some jaw dropping wide angled vistas near the third act.  Shot on location at the Canyon de Chelly by Virgil Miller whose work was nominated for Best Cinematography despite having limited means and only one camera to his disposal, Navajo at times functions like a silent picture where you needn’t be able to hear the dialogue to determine the nature of this story.  

With his camera, Miller and director Foster all but pave the way for seven-year-old Indian actor Francis Kee Teller who carries the film on his shoulders despite never having seen one in his life before.  Filmed under the working title The Voice of the Wind with a miniscule $30,000 budget amid threatens of bans by the Indian Service coupled with inclement weather conditions, Navajo for all its accomplishments seemed to have the world against it.
 
In the end however, Navajo earned almost universal acclaim from critics and audiences alike, copping two Academy Award nominations.  Seen now, certain elements of the film (revealed years later) date the film such as child actor Sammy Ogg doing a Native American accent in the voiceover narration instead of Francis Kee Teller.  Also, despite running just over an hour the first half of the film tends to meander somewhat as Son of the Hunter and his family are on the move hunting for a new home.  


While not necessarily an unearthed classic eagerly awaiting rediscovery, Navajo nevertheless takes its place in movie history as among the very first times Hollywood tried to tell the Native American life story using real Native Americans instead of professional movie actors.  A curious if not beautiful cinematic docudrama object that hasn’t completely aged well but is still a fascinating time capsule.

--Andrew Kotwicki