Cinematic Releases: Consecration (2023) - Reviewed

Courtesy of IFC Midnight
Does anyone remember the 2010 Sean Bean and Eddie Redmayne starring Medieval England horror film Black Death?  It was a movie filled with incredible atmosphere and a solid premise drawing heavily from the likes of Witchfinder General or Mark of the Devil with its mixture of superstition and supernatural elements that sadly never quite delivered on the strength of its promise.  A beautiful vehicle to look at that doesn’t take off or land, director Christopher Smith’s Black Death is important to consider with respect to said director’s return to the very genre he clearly loves but doesn’t seem to understand: the IFC Midnight/Shudder original religious hysteria horror film Consecration. 

 
After the mercurial death of her priest brother, Grace (Jena Malone affecting a British accent) ventures out to the Mount Savior Convent deep within Scotland’s rocky terrain to get her own answers, leading her to the usual discoveries involving a dysfunctional convent ruled by a domineering Mother Superior who comes across as suspect immediately when she deprives Grace of her belongings and tries to shield her from the truth.  Doubting the convent’s version of the story, she digs deeper and discovers a trail of ritualistic murder and an omnipresence of supernatural evil which may or may not be linked to Grace herself.  From here we get the usual candlelit warfare between good and evil spirits while its main overqualified cast members Jena Malone and Danny Huston are tragically underutilized.

 
Almost thirteen years later, the same shortcomings that torpedoed Black Death are repeating themselves here with all the chips in place but no game wins.  For all of its stately split-diopter widescreen cinematography and the pedigree of leading cast members Jena Malone and Danny Huston, Consecration self-terminates before the thing ever really gets to begin.  For a film that purports to be evoking the convent mania of Ken Russell’s The Devils, this is every bit as dulling and spineless as The Conjuring tie-in The Nun was.  Despite some strong and tense flashbacks involving Grace and her younger brother being abused and caged up as children by their insane father, Consecration is neither frightening nor engaging and kind of lays there like a dead animal.
 
Picked up by IFC Midnight and Shudder who have recently put out such gems as Hatching or Watcher, films that definitely did live up to the reputation of both labels, Consecration for the initiated and uninitiated is, yes, picturesque but otherwise a tedious yawn that occasionally splatters blood but never lets loose on the mayhem, say, Paul Verhoeven unleashed with Benedetta.  All the ornate cinematography, editing and moody ambient music in the world can't disguise the fact that there's not that much of a story here let alone told in a way people won't get bored with.


Considering the fires actors Jena Malone and Danny Huston stoked themselves in the past, with Malone’s unforgettable twisted makeup artist in The Neon Demon to Danny Huston’s troubled hotshot Hollywood agent in ivansxtc, one expects their talents to lend some credibility to Consecration, a film that had all the ingredients in place to be a real dose of old-fashioned nunsploitation.  Unfortunately as a fan of such fare as The Devils, Benedetta, AlucardaKiller Nun and of course The Exorcist as far as demonic hysterical horror films go, Consecration barely musters up a whimper before it withers up and dies a quiet death. 

--Andrew Kotwicki