Cinematic Releases: The Miracle Club (2023) - Reviewed

Images courtesy of Sony Pictures Classics

Irish Spectre Productions co-founder and Ordinary Decent Criminal director Thaddeus O’Sullivan has been active in distinctly Irish cinema and television since the 1990s with December Bride before working his way up to The Heart of Me and Stella Days.  His latest endeavor, the Dublin and Lourdes shot ensemble drama The Miracle Club about a group of middle-class largely elderly women band together for a pilgrimage in the water Sanctuary of Lourdes, functions as a film about self-actualization, healing old wounds and possibly a bona fide miracle at hand.  The resulting film is a bit like a Stephen Frears film, adorned with an eclectic cast with a fairly light character driven drama with moments of unexpected dramatic power.  Light on the surface but hinting at heavier weathers.

 
Close friends Lily (Maggie Smith), Eileen (Kathy Bates) and Dolly (Agnes O’Casey) reside in the Ballygar community of Dublin, Ireland put on a song-and-dance show to win a contest for pilgrimage at the Lourdes, France sanctuary.  Much to their respective husbands’ chagrin, the trio packs up and embarks for Lourdes.  As they’re about to depart however, an old estranged friend named Chrissie (Laura Linney) arrives for her mother’s funeral, triggering unrest over heartache and past unresolved wounds.  Hastily tagging along on the trip to Lourdes, the endeavor is fraught with turmoil as these women find themselves in friction with Chrissie whose presence threatens to upend the whole trip. 

 
A soft, warm-hearted movie for Irish moms and elder filmgoers while also functioning as a fairly well mounted ensemble drama with light elements of humor and Maggie Smith and Kathy Bates delivering quick witted snarky quips over the arrival of Laura Linney’s estranged friend.  One of the charms of the film is how these hard-working stay-at-home women go for their dream while the annoyed working husbands get a hard dose of parenthood they’ve always relied on their wives for.  These gals don’t take no for an answer and aren’t about to be deterred by their male companions.  One particularly charming appearance onscreen is that of Kathy Bates’ husband played by The Company of Wolves actor Stephen Rea who acts gruff and tough but quickly recognizes his place in the scheme of things.
 
Lensed handsomely in panoramic widescreen by Flora and Son cinematographer John Conroy and given a soft orchestral score by The Dark composer Edmund Butt, part of the purpose of The Miracle Club is a travelogue, showing off Ireland before moving over to the splendor of Lourdes, France and going through the sacred water baths containing miracles.  The cast across the board is great as always with Maggie Smith having found her niche post-Downton Abbey and Kathy Bates fresh off of Richard Jewell is a wonderfully feisty presence.  Laura Linney’s character is somewhat sad and treated like the black sheep of the group but as always Linney channels strong emotional weathers in her performance.  The newcomer here is Agnes O’Casey in only her debut as a mother with a son who won’t speak in the hopes a trip to Lourdes will coax him out of his muteness.


Sweet natured, gentle and languid, The Miracle Club is lighthearted Irish fare with lovely performances and a moving story about a group of friends who seek out a miracle but find something perhaps greater about themselves in the process.  The film isn’t about to win any awards or break new ground, but as comfort food it mostly does the job right.  Thaddeus O’Sullivan will probably continue to serve up soft Irish dramas for some time but in this case he gets an added boost from his eclectic cast and the significance of the Lourdes Sanctuary itself.  A nice little November movie to watch at home curled up on the couch by the cozy fireplace.

--Andrew Kotwicki