31 Days of Hell/Cinematic Releases: Totally Killer (2023) - Reviewed

Images courtesy of Amazon Prime Video

American Dad executive producer and Young Rock co-creator Nahnatchka Khan, in her second official feature following the Netflix produced romantic comedy Always Be My Maybe has officially joined forces with the Blumhouse team in the new forthcoming Amazon Prime original film Totally Killer.  A postmodern riff on the teen slasher horror flick, science fiction time travel comedy, nostalgia piece for a bygone era and just a plain old fun October film to drop right in time for Halloween.  As a critic and devoted horror fan still getting over the stench farted out in David Gordon Green’s disgraceful The Exorcist Believer, Totally Killer is a bit refreshing for mixing the slasher scream queen driven horror comedy with meta fourth wall breaking elements ala Happy Death Day or Freaky which tonally it has the most in common with.

 
Opening on a flashback on the story of the Sweet Sixteen Killer on Halloween in the town of Vernon who murdered several of Jamie Hughes’ (Kiernan Shipka) parents’ friends at a Halloween party, the disgruntled modern high-schooler trying to maneuver the overprotective clutches of mother Pam (Julie Bowen) and her father Blake (Lochlyn Munro).  One fateful Halloween night, the killer returns and despite her best efforts at self-defense, Pam is killed.  A devastated Jamie learns one of her best friends at the school science fair has somehow or another made a makeshift time-machine out of a telephone booth (Bill and Ted’s Excellent Adventure anyone?) and the idea hatches of going back in time to stop the killer before the crime even happens. 
 
Chased by the killer herself into the time machine, she finds herself transported back to 1987 in an effects heavy montage Time After Time style with frequent name drops of a certain Back to the Future movie.  Befriending mean girl Pam (played by Olivia Holt as a teen) and bumping into hot jock Blake (Charlie Gillespie), the film then becomes a bit of a synth heavy sleepover slasher type of horror comedy with a lot of self-references as Jamie tries to alter the course of the future and still make it back home alive.  Then the film starts the time-honored tradition of keeping you and the survivors guessing who the killer might be with suspicion cast on everyone including Jamie herself.

 
Written by Workaholics producer Jen D’Angelo and The Muse actress Sasha Perl-Raver, co-starring Always Be My Maybe actor Randall Park as a cynical police officer and a host of young newcomers, Totally Killer is both a whimsically tongue-in-cheek throwback to distinctly mid-80s slasher horrors while channeling the clashing cultural timelines of the old and new while making its influences plain as day.  Including but not limited to calling out Back to the Future, the film also is also a cacophony of cool needle drops of the day such as New Order’s Bizarre Love Triangle and Echo & The Bunnymen’s The Killing Moon which naturally made me think of Donnie Darko.  And speaking of that movie, the film recruits the same composer of that film Michael Andrews who provides a suitably synthesized period score of the 1980s.  Lensed by Young Rock cinematographer Judd Overton, the film has the look of a made-for-television streamer which isn’t ideal but is otherwise fine for this kind of low budget horror slasher.
 
Acting wise the ensemble cast is fine with Mad Men actress Kiernan Shipka giving viewers a spunky scream queen who was trained how to fight by her parents, sidestepping the cliches of damsels in distress running away from a knife wielder.  Probably the most seasoned horror veteran in the piece is character actor Lochlyn Munro as Kiernan’s father who has been in everything from Scary Movie to Freddy vs. Jason.  Hubie Halloween actress Julie Bowen is back for more October oriented shenanigans as Kiernan’s mother, played with sharp tongued relish as a teen by Olivia Holt.  Most of the rest of the cast is made up of teen actors who generally do a good job of behaving in a decidedly unprogressive era, replete with crass references to sex, subtle racism and frequent head butting between 2023 Jamie Hughes and the slightly archaic world she’s been transported back into.

 
A nice little treat for slasher horror comedy fans eager to kick back and have some old-fashioned fun, this clever Amazon Prime Original streamer released under the new Blumhouse Television banner is a delightful little made-for-TV film.  While not as polished or fully furnished as some of the other more recent examples of the same like the aforementioned Happy Death Day films, its heart is in the right place and as such feels like a cleaner digital version of a regional exploitation slasher with a snarky smirk and tongue firmly planted in cheek.  Not particularly scary but a fun slasher thriller and playful spin on Back to the Future lore.  Think of it as Freaky by way of Are You Afraid of the Dark?

--Andrew Kotwicki