Arrow Video: Witness (1985) - Reviewed

Images courtesy of Paramount Pictures

It goes without saying retired Australian filmmaker Peter Weir is one of the world’s greatest living film directors.  Though hanging his hat in 2010 with his last film The Way Back, Weir’s career spans all the way back to 1971 with his debut films Homesdale and 1974’s The Cars That Ate Paris before embarking on his first real true cinematic masterpiece with the legendary mystery period thriller Picnic at Hanging Rock.  A keen social observer who drops his viewers into a particular setting before the chess pieces of the story gradually fall into place, the master filmmaker continued his artistic ascension with such critically acclaimed fare as The Last Wave, Gallipoli and The Year of Living Dangerously before landing on the 1985 film that would garner eight Academy Award nominations for the director: the snapshot of Amish life as a bad cops genre thriller Witness starring Harrison Ford in arguably his most complete performance as an actor.

 
Within a Pennsylvania Amish community circa 1984, widowed mother Rachel (Kelly McGillis) and her eight-year-old son Samuel (Lukas Haas) are on their way to the train station to visit her sister in Philadelphia when at the 30th Street Station, Samuel wanders into the men’s room and from his bathroom stall witnesses two men brutally murdering an undercover police officer.  Assigned to the case is Detective John Book (Harrison Ford) who discovers through the witness a ring of police corruption resulting in an attempt on his life in a parking garage, forcing him, Rachel and Samuel to go into hiding within the Amish community.  Much to Rachel’s father-in-law’s chagrin, the injured Book slowly recovers and starts to blend in with the Amish community becoming one of their own, igniting impassioned romantic longings within Rachel despite being from two vastly different worlds.  Still the killers haven’t forgotten and eventually slowly descend on the quiet Amish community looking for Book and the key witness to their crimes.

 
A bilingual snapshot of the water and electricity free covered wagons Amish way of life that gradually develops into a genre thriller and then a kind of Romeo & Juliet doomed romance involving two people from vastly different ways of life, Witness while partially a police movie is largely about the modern world clashing with the old.  In a series of opening shots beautifully photographed by Academy Award winning cinematographer John Seale (Mad Max: Fury Road), the camera careens over grassy fields and plains as legendary composer Maurice Jarre’s ethereal electronic score swells to life, we get the feeling of being transported back in time.  Only when a covered wagon on the highway slows down a semi-truck and generates heavy traffic and car horns honking are these two disparate worlds and timelines clashing together.  While ostensibly a thriller, it then becomes something of a fish-out-of-water story as John Book immerses himself in the Amish community and starts tugging at the heartstrings of widowed Rachel.

 
Acting wise, this is probably Harrison Ford’s finest hour onscreen in a role not only well researched but hiding a quiet burning passion which only erupts at key times such as a brief encounter with some local bullies that gives away his ruse.  Ford has always been a talented and charismatic actor but here he imbues his character with subtlety and nuance and winds up saying a lot more with his facial expressions and his eyes than with words.  Kelly McGillis too spent a great deal of time in an Amish community learning the farm working way of life but also exuding herself a sexual tension and yearning purely with her facial expressions.  The supporting cast is also strong with child actor Lukas Haas from Testament as the unintended witness to a crime, Josef Sommer as the chief of police, Danny Glover as one of the assassins and Die-Hard actor Alexander Godunov as Rachel’s on/off lover.
 
Ornate, carefully composed and like his other works Picnic at Hanging Rock or The Truman Show leaving the audience with connecting the dots on their own, Witness is one of the very best films of the 1980s, garnering eight Oscar nominations including Best Picture and Best Actor for Harrison Ford.  Both a slice-of-life regard for the Amish community on film and a neo-noir crime thriller, Weir’s grand and quietly stirring American epic while celebrated has been in less than stellar home video editions for a moment there.  From Paramount Pictures’ first DVD run rife with problems, it seemed like Witness would languish in insufficient home video releases for awhile.  That is until just recently with Arrow Video’s gargantuan deluxe limited edition 4K UHD set.  Stacked with archival extras including electronic press kits as well as new visual essays and a video interview with the film’s cinematographer, the film has never looked or sounded better including both the original 2.0 Dolby Stereo mix and a remixed 5.1 DTS-HD track. 

 
Seen years later, Witness remains timeless and like you’re being transported into another world years apart from our own.  As an actor’s piece, it is powerful, passionate stuff with Ford and McGillis’ unfulfilled romantic longings slowly burning over into view.  For Weir, the film functions as both a genre thriller and a social study of a way of life entrenched in the past traditions with an outsider thrust into that world with forever altering ramifications.  Still a masterpiece by one of cinema’s still greatest living directors, Witness bridges something of an artistic gap for Peter Weir, finding a way to function as docudrama with a portrait of Amish lifestyle within the prism of a crime thriller.  Unquestionably one of the most important home video releases of the year for Arrow Video.

--Andrew Kotwicki