Mary Pickford: Stella Maris (1918) - Reviewed

Images courtesy of the Mary Pickford Company

Canadian film actress, screenwriter and studio founder Gladys Marie Smith, otherwise known in the film industry as Mary Pickford, was one of the US film industry’s greatest pioneers and titans.  Having formed with her husband Douglas Fairbanks the Pickford-Fairbanks Studios company as well as the legendary United Artists, “America’s sweetheart” girl “with the curls” almost immediately cemented herself as the queen of the Classical Hollywood Cinema era.  A frequent collaborator of D.W. Griffith in the early 1900s, the actress eventually worked her way up through the industry, landing her a feature film contract with Adolph Zukor in 1916 for Paramount Pictures under their sublabel Artcraft. 

 
With the foundation of the Mary Pickford Company and in conjunction with the Library of Congress, an extensive restoration was undertaken for her 1918 film Stella Maris directed by Marshall Neilan.  Based on William John Locke’s 1913 novel of the same name, the film nearly fell into the usual fates of silent film oblivion due to wear and tear and time until the Mary Pickford Foundation and Paramount Film Archive sought to gather together all the surviving elements to reconstruct the most complete version of the film available.  Though the COVID-19 pandemic forced the archives to close up for two years, they still managed to work out a deal where the elements could be scanned in 4K and further restored into a watchable print.  Though the elements themselves were incomplete, this is as close to the original release version as it was seen by hand-cranked projection speed 19fps in 1918.

 
On the cusp of WWI with scenes of soldiers marching past the estate, Stella Maris (Mary Pickford) is born paralyzed and immobile while her overprotective wealthy legal guardians do their best to shield her from the ills of the world.  Bedbound, she is unaware of the war breaking out around her or that people are impoverished.  Meanwhile established journalist and family friend John Risca (Conway Tearle) has been unhappily married to alcoholic Louise (Marcia Manon) for several years but gets some respite through visiting Stella Maris.  After hiring an uneducated orphaned servant named Unity Blake (Mary Pickford again) who loses her groceries while shopping to some juvenile delinquents, Louise savagely beats the orphan and gets arrested and sentenced to three years in prison while John Risca and the Maris family take the battered youth under their wing to care for her, eventually pitting Unity Blake and Stella Maris (two Mary Pickfords) onscreen together through a wild technical visual effects feat.

 
A silent melodrama aided by a newly rendered score by the Graves Brothers and shot beautifully in 1.37:1 by longtime Cecile B. DeMille collaborator Walter Stradling, the sepia tone tinted tale of two damaged frail souls who find unlikely solace in one another with a triangular love drama going on in the background is a sweet natured story with a sense of hope shining through all the darkness.  A real showcase for the incredible acting talents of Mary Pickford who despite only having reliance on intertitles for dialogue manages to create two very different characters who couldn’t look more dissimilar, Stella Maris also functions as a time capsule capturing a war breaking out in seemingly real time.  Despite some initial censorship that has since been restored, the film that significantly boosted the already strong commercial and critical appeal of Mary Pickford with an extraordinary performance that went on to become a huge commercial success.

 
The Mary Pickford Company restored release also comes on bluray courtesy of MVD Visual and VCI Entertainment a bonus biograph short film from Mary Pickford’s 1900 days as well as detailed liner notes breaking down the restoration as well as the creation of the new score.  A splendid addition to any cinematic historian’s library going back to the heart of old foundational Americana in a beautifully detailed release, Stella Maris despite the COVID-19 delays was worth the wait and the end results look glorious.  Mary Pickford’s contribution to cinema as one of the first true female pioneers of film remains as vital now as it was then and I look forward to the next impending restoration project from the Mary Pickford Company!

--Andrew Kotwicki