Cinematic Releases: Night Swim (2024) - Reviewed

Images courtesy of Universal Pictures

January is upon us and so is the hybrid mixture of post-2023 December releases and the so-called ‘dumping ground’ 2024 winter title drops where studios unsure of what to do with delayed or outright shelved movies clear some out.  While not all of it is bad with some of the previous year’s best films (The Zone of Interest notably) merely being pushed into the new year, the ‘dumping ground’ moniker is usually earned with good reason.  Equally of trend in specifically the horror subgenre are the proliferation of short films being developed and expanded into feature length projects, having done it with Come Play, Lights Out and now today’s Atomic Monster/Blumhouse merger Night Swim. 

 
Based off of a 2014 short film of the same name by writer-director Bryce McGuire and co-writer/director Rod Blackhurst, it told of a supernaturally haunted swimming pool which terrorizes and tries to consume/absorb the owner.  Running a brisk four minutes, the concept has now been fleshed out to involve an entire family moving into the household not knowing of the pool’s past.  Though slick with some striking visual effects and many obvious inspirations worn proudly on its sleeves, it never quite banks on the promise of the short or what lengths of horror lunacy we’ve come to expect from the production company behind Malignant or M3GAN.

 
Disabled former Milwaukee Brewers baseball star Ray (Wyatt Russell) and wife Eve Waller (Kerry Condon) move into a new house with their two children Izzy (Amélie Hoeferle) and Elliot (Gavin Warren).  Suffering from multiple sclerosis and slowly losing his mobility, Ray is struck by the therapeutic aspects of the swimming pool in his new home’s backyard and not long after immersing himself in the pool he seems to start healing.  However, at two different times Izzy and Elliot have terrifying supernatural encounters in the pool and soon the family notices a change in personality and physique of their father, building towards a bizarre if not a little absurd foray into Poltergeist pool fare including but not limited to zombies, a Viy-like monster and a lot of evil black sludge (Spider-Man 3 anyone?).

 
A handsomely shot, blocked and edited low budget thriller channeling everything from Poltergeist, The Amityville Horror, The Abyss and The Ring, despite these ingredients the film never fully kicks into the bonkers mode established by the previous aforementioned James Wan and Jason Blum offerings.  Shot in scope by Charlie Sarroff (probably the best aspect of the film) and given a serviceable horror score by Mark Korven who himself has done far better soundtracks for The Witch and The Lighthouse, Night Swim looks and sounds pretty with some shimmering underwater cinematography.  Performance wise the cast is fine though Oscar nominated Kerry Condon is stuck in a kind of thankless soccer mom role.  Wyatt Russell is generally good in expressing the dad’s subtle transformation though debatably the ones with the most heavy lifting are the child stars.

 
In theaters tomorrow, Night Swim is a decent if not mediocre January horror offering which sadly is among the weaker Atomic Monster/Blumhouse collaborations.  Though given a decent budget with some wild vistas near the end when it starts leaning more and more into James Cameron meets George A. Romero underwater fare, something is amiss in how it never fully reaches anywhere close to the heights of their prior offerings.  As a short film reworked into a feature it expands upon the source considerably but for all the noise and jump scares laced with fake outs the scares or outlandishness never really clicks.  All in all, a noble effort which like the pool water itself ripples and splashes about a little before returning to dull flatness.  With a setup and producing talent like this behind it, we surely should expect cannonballs!

--Andrew Kotwicki