The Sprocket Vault: Charley Chase at Hal Roach - The Late Silents (1927) - Reviewed

Images courtesy of Kit Parker Films

Kit Parker Films, MVD Visual and The Sprocket Vault have made their efforts to restore and re-release Hal Roach Studios comedies from it’s Golden Era have resulted in some of the best silent and sound comedy compendiums on the marketplace next to Flicker Alley.  With their Laurel & Hardy – The Definitive Restorations set which came out in 2020, the joint efforts by Kit Parker Films and CineMuseum LLC have produced a wonderful compilation of the beloved comedy duo and soon after they began setting their sights on some of the other notable Hal Roach comics who don’t have the same degree of recognition but nevertheless have an equal amount of comedic talent.

 
In the past Kit Parker Films began focusing on one of the original longtime collaborators of the Laurel & Hardy team with comedian Charley Chase who has appeared in everything from their silent works to some of their most well-known sound features like Sons of the Desert.  Among some of the previously released Charley Chase compilations have included DVD volumes of ‘The Talkies’ ranging from the late 1920s through the 1930s as well as some of the actor’s feature films overseen by Hal Roach.  With this new disc focusing on Charley Chase at Hal Roach – The Late Silents all made within 1927, Kit Parker Films and The Sprocket Fault with MVD Visual have upgraded to the blu-ray disc format for the first time with Charley Chase’s short film collection.  With elements gathered from around the world ranging from solid 35mm to rough 16mm, 8mm or even videotape sources, the restoration outfit have done their very best to try and bring many of these long-thought-to-be-lost short comedies to viewers today in the best quality possible.

 
With nearly all of the films directed by Charley Chase’s brother James Parrott with supervision by Leo McCarey, across two discs the set comprises fifteen shorts as well as three bonus shorts on the second disc and a running audio commentary by Hal Roach expert Richard M. Roberts.  All in black-and-white with some features missing some frames or, in the case of one an entire first reel with intertitles used to fill in the gaps, many of the films haven’t been seen in public since their original first release.  Before the set begins, there’s a preface from the restoration team explaining the varying quality of the shorts and in some cases an occasional drop in image resolution as a result of the years of wear and tear on the films.  Despite this, the films remain timelessly hilarious and showcase Charley Chase’s keen ability for playing off of the lunacy of Hal Roach comedy with his own riff on the classic Charlie Chaplin image.

 
Running roughly over 300 minutes with each short running approximately 20 apiece, for those familiar or uninitiated with the silent comedian (I myself have only seen him within Laurel & Hardy comedies), Charley Chase at Hal Roach – The Late Silents represents a wonderful introductory chapter and cause for celebration among fans of silent comedy.  While the transfers range from being pristine to poor, that is understandable considering the age and the restoration team have clearly put exhaustive work into bringing these century-old films back to life again.  Given the strength of this set, one hopes that down the line the same team behind this will perhaps go through the Charley Chase ‘Talkies’ series and provide them with a proper upgrade.  For now, this set is a blast and one of the most surprising delights of silent comedy ripe and waiting for rediscovery.

--Andrew Kotwicki