Now Streaming: The Premiere (2025) - Reviewed

 

Images Courtesy of Giant Pictures

Mockumentaries are one of the most solid genres of comedy films.  Awkwardness and idiosyncrasies are the tools of the trade and in Sam Pezzullo and Christopher Bouckoms' hilarious feature film The Premiere, they are married in a delightfully mad romance of self-centered egos, disastrous productions, and small-town crime.  Featuring a perfectly ridiculous central performance (one of the best of the year), a unique potpourri of Sag Harbor locals, and genuinely humorous moments of comedic timing, this is one of the most memorable comedies of the year. 

Sam is a failed theater producer who decides that it is his life’s dream to create a stage play based on 1996's slasher film Scream, a task that is a fool's errand.  In the wake of the failure, Sam decides to create a documentary on the failed production.  Bouckoms and Pezzullo's script will immediately conjure memories of Curb Your Enthusiasm and to a certain point, Best in Show.  The story within the story is a nice touch, and while having screen Scream is not a perquisite, it does help some of the jokes land better.  Pezzullo stars as Sam and his ability to portray one of the most annoying, egotistical, and out of touch people in existence is a near miracle.  The entire premise hinges on this performance and Pezzullo does not disappoint.  


Kristen Curcie gives a stalwart supporting turn as Sam's assistant, whose conclusive scene immediately conjures the avatar of Aubrey Plaza. This is a story about failed dreams and small-town eccentricities, and Curcie is a standout in both avenues.  Michaael Candelori's cinematography has an uncomfortable stillness during a lot of the dialogue and this only helps to ratchet up the cringe factor.  Particularly during the final act, as things begin to come together (fall apart) the viewer is captured, helplessly within Candelori's cinematic grasp and forced to watch the trainwreck as it unfolds and the result is a one of the most laugh out loud comeuppances in recent memory.

Now available for digital rental, The Premiere is an intelligent peek into the world of self-absorbed artists.  On the surface, a story about chasing dreams and making them real masks a selfish undercurrent filled with strange local personas and a protagonist (?) with an embarrassingly large sense of self.  Smart dialogue and Pezzullo's absolute commitment to the material elevate what could have been a forgettable indie into an unforgettable and fun comedy film that deserves to be revisited.  

--Kyle Jonathan