VCI Entertainment: Film Noir Classics Double Feature: D.O.A. and Borderline (1949 - 1950) - Reviewed

Images courtesy of VCI Entertainment

Whenever the moniker of VCI Entertainment comes up, I instinctively get leery.  More or less a public domain outfit with mostly poor quality transfers and some occasional once-in-a-blue-moon winners, VCI Entertainment today has inherited the position previously worn by Fox Lorber DVD which for a short time produced discs that looked worse than most VHS tape iterations.  Despite the middling image and sound quality and hastily thrown together extras, fans of the film noir subgenre are likely to clamor around the first in a series of Film Noir Classics Double Feature with Rudolph Maté’s 1949 murder mystery race-against-time thriller D.O.A. and William A. Seiter’s 1950 lovers-on-the-run undercover cop whodunit Borderline.  Though the picture quality of D.O.A. leaves much to be desired with frequent shakiness, scratches and a general lack of sharpness or contrast, both of these movies are indelible additions to a film noir disciple’s ever growing and expansive libraries.

 
In the first film of the two, D.O.A. or Dead on Arrival for short follows accountant and notary Frank Bigelow (Edmund O’Brien) who after a night out on the town for a drink discovers he’s been poisoned with no antidote in sight and no sign of the perpetrator.  Forced to venture out into San Francisco with only days left to live, his plight sends him through possible leads including his secretary pointing towards mercurial and psychotic characters including a murderous gangster played by Neville Brand.  Eventually it starts to crop up his work as a notary may have something to do with an effort to purge information of the sale of iridium to criminal forces and people whom he initially thought were close friends now turning up as mercenary adversaries.  Featuring a rousing score by the legendary Dimitri Tiomkin and dynamic, luminous and fluid camerawork by Ernest Lazlo of Kiss Me Deadly and a powerful leading performance by Edmund O’Brien who convincingly conveys the terror and desperation felt by Frank Bigelow, D.O.A. despite the less-than-stellar image quality is a surefire masterpiece of the film noir subgenre.

 
With the second film Borderline featuring Fred MacMurray (The Apartment) and Claire Trevor (Dead End and Stagecoach), we find ourselves in a labyrinthine undercover cop thriller involving a narcotics smuggling operation commandeered by a violent gangster Pete Ritchie (Raymond Burr) on the US/Mexican border outside of Los Angeles.  Due to the nature of the operation, finding any leads has proven difficult so Madeleine Haley (Claire Trevor) an LAPD officer and former OSS operative is tasked with venturing into Mexico undercover to try and woo her way into Ritchie’s good graces.  Unbeknownst to each other, she crosses paths with a gangster named Johnny Macklin (Fred MacMurray) who is also in fact an undercover officer.  With neither side aware of each other’s backgrounds, the two pair up believing each other to be two criminals in cahoots with Pete Ritchie.  All the while, the couple find themselves being pursued by Pete and his goons across desert terrain and hitchhiking their way across the Mexican border. 

 
A good crime thriller with shades of noir that ultimately becomes something of a crowd pleasing cops vs. robbers flick rather than qualifying completely as film noir, Borderline feels like it was tacked on to this release with the real treat being D.O.A.  But considering the lackluster picture quality of that film, doing a standalone release of just the former noir might’ve felt like a cheat so Borderline which has better remastering work but pales in comparison to D.O.A. has been included.  Notable for the filmmakers creating their own production company to finance the film with producer Milton Bren suggesting his wife, Academy Award winning actress Claire Trevor, for the lead role, Borderline is mostly a chase thriller with elements of It Happened One Night running through it right down to some of the hitchhiking. 

 
Both films included here have additional features focused on the careers of Edmund O’Brien, director Rudolph Maté
, Fred MacMurray and director William A. Seiter but again they’re rather generic and impersonal.  Not much else is on here though the Blu-ray comes with a DVD counterpart for those still stuck in the 480p era.  D.O.A. is a terrific and taut masterclass example of the film noir genre while Borderline was a mostly okay (good, not great) crime thriller and while the disc isn’t horrible, considering the pedigree of D.O.A. it deserved so much better than this present disc release.  You can’t go wrong with either film though D.O.A. is the one that will get frequent rewatching over the years while Borderline is kind of a one-and-done.  VCI Entertainment I’m still uneasy about but this was a mostly good double-feature release fans of film noir will want to grab up right away.

--Andrew Kotwicki