Criterion Corner: The Right Stuff (1983) - Reviewed

Images courtesy of Warner Brothers

Writer-director Philip Kaufman’s 1983 film adaptation of Tom Wolfe’s 1979 nonfiction book The Right Stuff chronicling the saga of the American space race is a monumental chunk of unexpurgated director-driven New Hollywood Cinema peaking around the time when the tide for such movies broke with Michael Cimino’s Heaven’s Gate (also a sprawling epic rife with historical significance and spectacle).  Spanning three decades over the course of three hours from Chuck Yeager’s (Sam Shepard) breaking of the sound barrier to the beginning of the Space Race against the Soviets leading to the space launches of several key astronauts including Alan Shepard (Scott Glenn), Gus Grissom (Fred Ward) and John Glenn (Ed Harris), it is a comprehensive trained uncompromising study of the hardships endured by several American pilots who can be characterized as national heroes.  With all of the good and bad, right and wrong on display including some medical testing scenes during the selection process of potential candidates that are still hard to watch now, the saga of The Right Stuff might be the most distinctly American historical dramatization of the Space Race ever attempted with only pale imitations including a recently cancelled Disney+ series appearing since. 
 
Narrated omnisciently by Air Force test pilot Jack Ridley (Levon Holm), the expanse of The Right Stuff begins with a preamble in postwar 1947 following numerous failed fatal test piloting accidents at the Muroc Army Airfield in California while flying the rocket powered Bell X-1.  Wartime hero and Captain Chuck Yeager (Sam Shepard) leaps at the chance to pilot the X-1 and following a nerve-wracking test flight Yeager successfully breaks the ‘demon in the sky’.  Initially a secret before the military becomes further involved in forming what will or won’t become the group of men with The Right Stuff, Yeager in reality declined participation in the program but the film version finds his own speed records being superseded by younger less qualified as well as prime piloting material recruits in training.  Then the Soviets launched the Sputnik satellite thus triggering the Space Race which excludes Yeager due to his lack of a college degree.  Eventually the Mercury Seven astronauts comprised of both marine and navy corps undergo a strenuous and difficult series of medical, physiological and psychological tests including being locked in a dark room with a ticking clock that hours later turns noisy and frightening.  Following Yuri Gagarin’s Soviet space flight on the Vostok 1, the determination of the seven astronauts with The Right Stuff becomes more immediate than ever in their unified goal to meet if not surpass their match.

 
Jaw dropping and awesomely uncompromising in scope and real-world endurances, The Right Stuff from Rocky and Raging Bull producers Irwin Winkler and Robert Chartoff is a mammoth powerhouse of the tail end of 1970s director driven filmmaking on the scale of Michael Cimino, Francis Ford Coppola or William Friedkin.  Though Philip Kaufman previously dabbled in science-fiction fantasy with his 1978 adaptation of Invasion of the Body Snatchers as well as penning the story with George Lucas for Raiders of the Lost Ark, The Right Stuff finds Kaufman wading in nuts-and-bolts hard boiled scientific fact and strips away the clean veneer of the Space Program’s image versus what transpired behind closed doors.  With medical examinations that range from Friedkin levels of harrowing to silly and hilarious without ever losing the sense of realism mixed in with the small-town American drive to transcend humankind’s own limited physical form, the film gives us the ugly truth like it or not however painful the endurances are to look upon.

 
In addition to being a mixture of urgent, frightening and thrilling historical biographical storytelling, The Right Stuff also leaves ample room for humor to sort of nurse the audience through some rather difficult scenes like the training processes doled out upon (or against?) the trainees.  Our first brush with Alan Shepard having electricity running through his hand in a lab test by a doctor in a white overcoat is cringe inducingly tense and hard to watch while one of our last medical tests involving a bladder balloon are close to achieving outright comedy.  There’s a medical test involving a stoic female doctor demanding a semen culture that starts out awkward but is played as an extended comic joke again detailing the lengths with which doctors would go to determine an astronaut-in-training’s limits.  Alan Shepard again gets a funny aside where he is on the launch pad and has to urinate but is told not to by nervous scientists, juxtaposed with people drinking and/or spilling coffee and Shepard’s increasingly strained reactions of holding his pee under duress.  One of the hardest PG rated films of the 1980s including Gus Grissom dropping the F-bomb a couple of times in key exclamations, make no mistake while about the space program and the astronauts, this is far from being a squeaky-clean family friendly endeavor despite some of the humor intended to soften the still sharp edges. 

 
Structurally speaking, while an ensemble piece shifting between several characters who have the proverbial The Right Stuff, the film ends up bookending with Chuck Yeager, played excellently with a measure of subtlety by Sam Shepard in a career best since Days of Heaven.  Given Yeager’s own role in launching the space program by breaking the sound barrier while being kept from the official Right Stuff lineup of astronauts, the film circles back to his own journey in challenging the limits of the space program as well himself.  Though the program launches without him, he nevertheless breaks another unforeseen record with the highest altitude to the edge of space the then-new Lockheed NF-104A and nearly loses his life in the process of reestablishing himself not just in the hearts and minds of the USAF, but in the audience’s connection to Yeager’s drive and spirit at the end of a three-hour saga.  In a film filled with many disparate characters and their own paths to success or upheaval depending, it all returns to Yeager’s drive and spirit to push humankind’s technological capabilities and wherewithal past its limit. 

 
While many point to Forrest Gump as a prime example of seamlessly interspersing newly shot scenes with preexisting footage involving the film’s hero interacting with important historical figures, 1983 was the year of both Woody Allen’s Zelig as well as The Right Stuff who inarguably beat Gump to the finish line by a decade.  Take for instance a mid-film montage of the astronauts observing failed rocket tests, using real footage captured of the explosions on the launch pad or midflight detonations with newly shot snippets plugged in with roughly the same finish.  Reminiscent of the melding of WWII footage with newly shot material ala Stuart Cooper’s Overlord, the film achieves a docudrama mixture that’s undetectable.  With Being There and The Natural cinematographer Caleb Deschanel’s understated and softly lit vistas lending a gritty grainy seriousness to the footage with an almost documentary-like quality, the patina of The Right Stuff ranges wildly from loudly vast to quietly insular.  Effects shots remain breathtaking and ambitious for their time including realistic miniature interpretations of space capsules orbiting the Earth upon the ferocious power of reentry into the Earth’s atmosphere.  Bill Conti’s score, maybe the most singularly American piece of compositional work since the musician’s own Rocky soundtrack, is much like the unfolding of Richard Strauss’ Also sprach Zarathustra.  Evocative, grandiose, terrifying but also triumphant in the struggle of exploration, Conti’s score ranges from thrilling and uplifting to downbeat and haunted.

 
Of course the film wouldn’t be able to portray the titular The Right Stuff properly were it not for the murderer’s row of an ensemble cast.  Starting with Sam Shepard as the all-American hero Chuck Yeager who ignites a run sadly (for the film’s sake) he’s not qualified to take part in, rounding out the cast of astronauts are Scott Glenn as Alan Shepard, Ed Harris as John Glenn, Dennis Quaid as Gordon Cooper, Fred Ward as Gus Grissom, Scott Paulin as Deke Slayton and Lance Henriksen as Wally Schirra.  Alongside them are their wives who go through all of the upheaval and turmoil with their husbands in person and when they’re away in orbit, played by Barbara Hershey as Glennis Yeager, Kim Stanley as Pancho Barnes, Veronica Cartwright fresh off of her prior Philip Kaufman stint in Invasion of the Body Snatchers as Betty Grissom and Mary Jo Deschanel as Annie Glenn.  Among the supporting cast members are The Thing and Popeye actor Donald Moffat as Lyndon B. Johnson, a then-unknown Jeff Goldblum as a nameless recruiter tasked with finding potential astronauts, The Thing actor David Clennon and at one point the real Chuck Yeager shows up in it.  Everyone gives 110% in this ensemble odyssey from the breaking of the sound barrier up through the numerous Earth orbiting missions and the respective episodes of pain, anguish but also triumph and success are portrayed with realism, abrasiveness but above all the American drive for conquering the impossible.

 
Premiering in October of 1983 at the Kennedy Center in Washington D.C. as part of a benefit to the American Film Institute, the film was given a limited run a few days later where it tragically grossed a meager $1.6 million on 229 screens.  Up against such box office titans as Return of the Jedi and Scarface, the following February of 1984 after effusive critical praise including Roger Ebert’s proclamation of ‘the best film of 1983’, Warner Brothers expanded the release to nationwide where it continued to flounder only garner a further $1.6 million in ticket sales.  Ultimately only grossing $21 million against a $27 million budget, the project led to the Chariots of Fire and Blade Runner production outfit The Ladd Company to fold and cease operations with Warner Brothers.  While eventually the company recovered in a new deal with Paramount Pictures including films like The Brady Bunch Movie and Braveheart, the expansive three-hour odyssey through the heart of the American spirit into the Space Race remained overlooked by the general public.  Nevertheless, that didn’t prevent the film from becoming an Awards favorite, securing eight Oscar nominations including Best Picture and winning four for Best Editing, Score, Sound and Sound Effects Editing.  Circa 2013, the film was selected for preservation in the US National Film Registry by the Library of Congress and was later ranked at number 19 on the AFI’s most inspiring movies list.

 
In 2013, the film finally saw a digitally restored Blu-ray release from Warner Brothers presented in proper 1.85:1 widescreen with restored 5.1 surround sound presumably taken from one of the many 70mm release prints.  Included with the release were selected scenes with cast and filmmaker commentaries, a 2003 making-of documentary and a historical documentary using archival interviews with the real astronauts.  There was also a feature-length documentary on John Glenn made in 1998 for PBS that was included.  And of course first buyers lucky enough to get it were treaded to a digibook release featuring notes and pictures of the production until it sold out and the discs were rereleased in a standard amaray case.  Now in 2026, Janus Films and The Criterion Collection have gone back to the original camera negative for a new forthcoming 4K UHD special edition featuring not one but three sound mixes including 2.0 stereo, 5.1 and the original 70mm six-track magnetic mix.  In addition to porting over the extras from the Warner Brothers disc, Criterion have generated new featurettes on the film’s extensive and pioneering visual effects and award-winning sound design and editing.  A testament to the American dream and spirit from top to bottom, The Right Stuff one of the greatest and most overlooked epic American masterpieces of cinema now has a chance to get its fair handshake and due in the hearts and minds of cinemagoers for the next millennia.  1980s American cinema rarely gets as staggeringly powerfully monumental as this.

--Andrew Kotwicki