Arrow Video: The Birthday (2004) - Reviewed

Images courtesy of Arrow Video

Spanish Timecrimes composer and Agnosia director Eugenio Mira made his filmmaking debut as a writer-director in 2004 with the Corey Feldman starring offbeat bizarro maximalist freakout The Birthday.  An English language Spanish produced film which played at the Sitges Film Festival followed by a theatrical release in Spain but no United States domestic distribution plan to speak of for almost twenty years.  Circa 2023, Jordan Peele, an avowed fan of the film, programmed it into Film at the Lincoln Center followed by an Alamo Drafthouse Cinemas 4K restoration for one-night-only in 2024.  

An offbeat uncategorizable mixture of socially awkward quirky paranoia, murder mystery and eventually increasingly Alex Cox-like elements of fantasy, science-fiction and just for fun some foggy nebulous Lynchian surrealism, The Birthday was never going to be an easy sell for the average moviegoer.  But in the era of boutique labels like Vinegar Syndrome or Arrow Video which is set to reissue The Birthday on a limited 4K disc, films like it that never got their fair handshake with the moviegoing public now have a chance to find an audience.

 
In for many a career-best performance from Corey Feldman (that honor still lies with Stand By Me for myself but I digress), the actor plays Norman Forrester, a lisping awkward dork in a suit attending his wealthy girlfriend Alison’s (Erica Prior) fancy birthday party commandeered by her patriarch father Ron (Pieces and Edge of the Axe actor Jack Taylor) with the intention of seizing on the moment to propose marriage to her.  However, as the night goes on with steadily bizarre encounters with other guests which may or may not include cocaine boozing parties, Norman trying to retrieve a birthday present for Alison ventures into the basement dwelling of the mansion revealing an otherworldly and perhaps intergalactic conspiracy where the fate of the world may hang on the balance.  All the while, Norman encounters a pitch perfect romcom staff of servants ala The Stepford Wives that eventually turn violent, building up towards noisy furious pandemonium you never saw coming from the film’s first hour.

 
A movie that begins like a screwball comedy that gradually slowly turns into a madcap maximalist freakout of sensory overload and excess ala Darren Aronofsky’s mother! with the fragmented narrative and tonal shifts of a David Lynch film where you’re not sure whether to laugh or scream, The Birthday was never going to be for all tastes.  From Corey Feldman’s genuinely peculiar and sometimes annoying performance with his strange accent and kind of bumbling anxiousness, it takes a bit of getting used to him in the role and a recent viewing of the documentary Corey Feldman vs. The World didn’t help.  


Still, it represents an interesting, singular performance from Feldman who for once isn’t just playing himself and actively is trying to disappear into a character.  Supporting players are also good, notably Jack Taylor who is a legendary character acting presence on the single room set and Erica Prior is tasked with holding her own against a freakish Corey Feldman.  Visually speaking, the film shot in scope 2.35:1 widescreen by Nowhere cinematographer Unax Mendia looks lovely and achieves the effect of a pressure-cooking chamber piece over time while the score by director Mira himself provides the peculiar Jonny Greenwood sounding score.

 
Previously without distribution in the United States for twenty years until now thanks to Arrow Video’s 4K UHD limited edition set, The Birthday features a new audio commentary co-opted by Feldman and Mira, a new video interview with Mira, archival behind-the-scenes featurettes and a new 2024 q&a with Mira and Feldman regarding the film’s legacy and reevaluation.  For someone coming into this with all the baggage Feldman has been wearing on his sleeves for the past ten years, at first it was a hard sell but eventually slowly it began to take the shape of a Twilight Zone episode which speaks volumes to Jordan Peele’s admiration for it.  Feldman’s a troubled actor not in his best place creatively or personally, but for what its worth The Birthday I can absolutely point to as one of his career highlights, a rare chance to see him in a different light embracing a surreal and interesting shapeshifting narrative in a film that doesn’t easily fit into any clean-cut niche.

--Andrew Kotwicki